Review types in a performance review cycle

A performance review cycle can include any combination of four review types. This article defines each type and links to instructions for completing them.

Note: Your organization may have renamed this feature. If you don't see "Performance Reviews" in your navigation, check with your admin for the name used in your account.

Key Rules

  • A cycle can include one, several, or all four review types — your admin configures which types are active.
  • Not all review types appear in every cycle. You only see and complete the types your admin has enabled.
  • Each review type has a separate submission workflow. See Related Articles below for step-by-step instructions.
  • In a cycle set to With 15Five AI, self, manager, and additional-manager reviews can receive AI-Assisted Reviews functionality. Peer and upward reviews use the same new review experience but do not include AI drafting, the Context library, Moments, or the review assistant. This is different from the legacy experience, which is a separate cycle-level choice.
  • Review types are chosen when the cycle is created and can be changed until the cycle starts. Once a cycle starts, its review types are locked, so you can't add or remove one. To collect upward reviews later, run a separate cycle that includes the Upward review type. See What review cycle settings can and cannot be changed after launch?
  • Manager Effectiveness questions in a self or manager review are about the participant as a manager. The participant answers them in the self review, and the participant's manager answers them in the manager review. These are not upward reviews. To collect ratings from a manager's direct reports, include the Upward review type. For reviewer identity settings, see Configure peer and upward review settings (Admin).

Review Types

Review Type Who Writes It Who It Is About
Self The participant Themselves
Manager The participant's direct manager (and any additional managers assigned by an admin) The participant
Peer A coworker nominated to give feedback The participant
Upward A direct report Their manager

Related Articles

Was this article helpful?

Sorry to hear that. Tell us what was missing →