Review submitted peer reviews of my team

Your direct reports' peers have submitted their peer reviews. Now it is your turn as the manager to review what the peers said about your direct reports' progress. It is key that you review the peer reviews submitted about your direct reports for a few reasons. One, to be informed for the final meeting with your direct report. Two, to ensure all answers are appropriate and effective and remove if not. This assumes that review administrators chose the setting that allows you to remove feedback. And three, to prepare any action items that you or your direct report need to take post meeting. Knowing those things, this article walks you through how view peer reviews that have been submitted.

Peer review process overview 

  • Once a peer review has been submitted for one of your direct reports, either participant initiated or peer initiated, you will receive an in-app notification. These are peer reviews that have been written about your direct report(s). 
  • After submission/notification, you can open the peer review. As a manager, you do have the ability to remove feedback that is not constructive on these peer reviews (if the setting is enabled for the review cycle).
  • There is also a setting that review admins can enable which hides all peer feedback from being shared verbatim with the participant. If this setting is enabled for the cycle, you will see a note at the top of the peer reviews letting you know that the participant (your direct report) will not see the peer answers verbatim and that you should include the peer feedback in your summary.
  • If you are an additional manager for a participant, you will also be able to view peer reviews upon submission. Anyone that you are an additional manager for will appear under the 'My team' filter on the cycle overview page. Use the same steps as below to view submitted peer reviews.
  • Depending on the review settings, the identity of the peer review author may be hidden from you.
  • Peer reviews are not visible to the direct report until you share the results. This usually is the very last step in the review cycle. If peer reviews are hidden from the participant, they will never see the peer answers verbatim, even after you have shared the results. 
  • You will not be able to edit/remove feedback from the peer review once results have been shared.
  • If peer reviews are not submitted before you finalize the review, they cannot be submitted. Keep this in mind as you finalize your direct reports' reviews.

View peer reviews for your team

1. Click on Best-Self Review® from the left navigation.


2. Click on the name of the cycle you need to work on. It will be under the 'Active review cycles' section.


3. From the 'Overview' tab, you will see a drop-down menu with options Me, My team, My hierarchy, and Everyone. Depending on your role and the visibility settings for the cycle, you may not see My hierarchy and Everyone.




If you have a large number of direct reports participating, you can also search for a specific person in the search field and then complete steps 5-6.

4. Click the My team option.


5. Scroll down to 'Review progress' for your team, click the ... next to the participant whose peer reviews you want to view, and then click View.


6. You'll land on a reviews page for that person and there will be a 'Peer' tab after the 'Self' tab. This 'Peer' tab houses all peer reviews that have been submitted for your direct report.


7. If peer reviews are hidden from the participant, your direct report, you will see the yellow message shown below. 


The peer reviews are only hidden from the participant, and not from review administrators, the hierarchy, or an additional manager if applicable. It is a reminder of the visibility settings and also a reminder to include the peer feedback in your summary of answers. It is important that the peer review results be conveyed to the participant in order to maintain a fair and objective review. 

8. Review the peer content and use this information to help you complete your Summary tab and help guide your final meeting. 

Was this article helpful?
0 out of 1 found this helpful