Analyze Review Results: Performance Ratings+ Reporting

15Five's Performance Ratings+ (PR+) tool offers a data-driven view of employee performance by combining scores from self and manager reviews. With PR+ reporting, you can explore individual ratings, compare performance across teams or demographic segments, and track trends over time—empowering you to make informed, equitable decisions around compensation, promotions, and development.

This article contains the following sections:

Access and availability

⛔️ Required access to Best-Self Review® Reporting.
👥 This article is relevant to Review admins, Cycle collaborators, and Managers.
📦 This feature is available in the Perform and Total Platform pricing packages.


Visibility into Performance Ratings 👀

  • Review Admins and Cycle Collaborators can view performance ratings for all participants in the review cycle.
  • Managers can view performance ratings for their direct reports.
  • If hierarchy visibility is enabled in feature settings, skip-level managers can view performance ratings for employees within their reporting hierarchy.
  • If the performance rating is visible to review participants setting is enabled in feature settings, participants can see their own performance rating.

Learn more about visibility settings in Best-Self Review® →


Use Performance Ratings+ Reporting 📊

  1. Click Performance in 15Five's main, left-hand navigation and select Best-Self Review® from the dropdown menu.
    BSR-New-Nav.png
  2. Open the relevant review cycle.
    Open-Active-Cycle.png
  3. Open the Company's results or Team's results tab. The tab you see will depend on whether or not you have an administrative role in the review cycle.
    Companys-Results-Tab-BSR.png
  4. You'll land on the Summary tab of review results. Scroll down to the Performance Ratings+ section.
    BSR-Results-Summary-PerformanceRatings%2B.png
  5. Apply filters to narrow your view and analyze results for specific employee cohorts.
    Filters-BSR-Summary-Tab.png
    • Use the People filter to view results for your direct reports, your hierarchy, or specific individuals, groups, or manager groups.
    • Use the Demographics & People Data filter to view results by demographic attribute (Age, Ethnicity, Gender, Race, or Salary) segments.
    💡

    Tip

    Save time and ensure consistent reporting by clicking Presets > Save Current as Preset to store your selected People and Demographics filters. HR admins can share presets with one another to standardize reporting across cycles. Learn more about filter presets →

  6. You can also use the Compare By Attribute dropdown at the top of the performance ratings table to analyze ratings side-by-side by demographic segments.
    Compare-By-Performance-Ratings.png
  7. Review the distribution of performance ratings. Hover over any answer section to view how many participants received that rating.
    Performance-Ratings-Hover.png
  8. To drill down, click the three dots to the right of the Performance Ratings+ graph and select View score distribution. This opens the Performance Ratings+ Detail page. Continue to the next section of this article to learn more about using this page.
    View-Score-Distribution.png

Use the Performance Ratings Details Page 🔍

The Performance Ratings+ Details page gives you deeper insight into employee performance ratings by allowing you to break down, compare, and track results over time. Use this page to move beyond the summary view and uncover trends across individuals, groups, and review cycles.

Here's how to use it:

  1. Apply filters to narrow your view. Just below the question, you can apply filters to customize the results.
    Filters-Performance-Ratings-Details.png
    • Groups filter: Focus on a specific group, such as your hierarchy or a department.
    • Review cycles filter: Select one or more review cycles to view results from.
    • Ratings filter: Choose a specific rating to analyze.
  2. Once you open the Performance Ratings+ Detail page, you can access three reports that allow you to analyze results in different ways. Each report includes a chart and Individuals table, allowing you to explore summary data and participant-level details. Use the dropdowns below to learn more about these reports.

    Score Distribution

    View how participants were distributed across performance ratings and drill into individual responses.

    This report displays a bar chart that shows the percentage of participants who received each rating. It helps you understand how ratings are spread across your organization and highlights employees at either end of the performance spectrum.

    Here's how to use it:

    1. View answer distribution. Use the bar chart to see the percentage of employees who received each performance rating.
      Performance-Rating-Bar-Chart.png
    2. Filter the report. Click on a rating to filter the Individuals table below to only include participants who received that rating.

      PerformanceRatings%2B-Score-Distribution-Table-Zoom.png

    3. Review individual data. Use the Individuals table to examine participant-level ratings. Each row shows the participant's name, their manager, the rating they received, and review cycle name.

    Compare Groups

    Break down and compare performance ratings across teams, departments, or other group types.

    Use this report to compare performance ratings across different manager teams, hierarchies, or group types to uncover patterns and disparities.

    Here's how to use it:

    1. Adjust filters. In addition to the Groups, Review cycles, and Answer filters available in every performance ratings report, the Compare Groups tab includes additional options to help focus your analysis.
      Compare-Groups-Filters.png
      • Use the View by filter to group results by Manager, Hierarchy, or Group type.

      • Use the Sort by filter to sort results alphabetically or by positivity of responses.

    2. Interpret the chart. The bar chart shows what percentage of each group received each rating.

      PR-Answer-Distribution-Hover.png

      💡

      Tip

      Hover over any color segment to see how many people received that rating.

    3. Review individual data. The Individuals table lists participants in the selected groups and the performance ratings they received. Use column headers to sort results as needed.
      PerformanceRatings%2B-Compare-Groups-Individuals-Table.png

    Trends Over Time

    Analyze how performance scores have shifted across multiple review cycles.

    This report provides a longitudinal view of performance ratings so you can track patterns and momentum over time.

    Here's how to use it:

    1. Select review cycles. Use the Review cycles filter at the top of the page to select two or more cycles to compare.

      Select-Reivew-Cycles-BSR-Results.png

      ✏️

      Note

      To view company-wide trends, you must be a review admin or cycle collaborator for all selected cycles.

    2. Interpret the trend graph. The line chart shows how performance ratings have changed from one cycle to the next. Each point on the line represents a review cycle.

      PerformanceRatings%2B-Trends-Over-Time-Chart.png

      💡

      Tip

      Hover over a point to see the overall distribution of performance ratings for that cycle.

    3. Review individual data. The Individuals table lists all participants included in the selected review cycles and the ratings they received. If a participant was reviewed in multiple cycles, they’ll appear more than once—once for each rating. Use column headers to sort data as needed.
      PerformanceRatings%2B-Trends-Over-Time-Individuals-Table.png

Available Downloads 📥

Summary Page

Performance Ratings+ report

Includes the distribution of performance ratings for participants that match selected filters. Allows you to see how many people fall into each performance rating.

To download this report, click Download in the top, right-hand corner of the 'Performance Ratings+' box on the review summary page.

Columns included in this download: Performance Rating, Score Range, Rating description, Participant count, Participant

Performance Ratings+ details page

Performance ratings score distribution report

Contains performance rating category information and how many participants (# and %) fall into each category.

To download this report, click ... next to the 'Performance Ratings+' section of the results summary tab and select 'View all answers' from the dropdown menu. Then, click Download in the top, right-hand corner of the score distribution table.

Columns included in this download: Performance Rating, Score Range, Rating description, Participant count, Participant %

Performance ratings score distribution/participant view report

Includes a list of all participants who received a specific performance rating.

To download this report, click ... next to the 'Performance Ratings+' section of the results summary tab and select 'View all answers' from the dropdown menu. Then, click Download in the top, right-hand corner of the individuals table.

Columns included in this download: Participant, Reviewer, Rating, Rating description, Overall score, Review cycle

Performance ratings compare groups report

Includes all groups that meet selected filters and what # and % of group members fell into each ratings category.

To download this report, click ... next to the 'Performance Ratings+' section of the results summary tab and select 'View all answers' from the dropdown menu. Then, open the 'Compare groups' tab and click Download in the top, right-hand corner of the compare groups chart.

Columns included in this download: Group name, Ratings Category Label (for each ratings category), Ratings Category Count (for each ratings category), Ratings Category Percentage (for each ratings category)

Performance ratings compare groups/participant view report

Includes a list of all participants that match selected filters and what rating and score they received.

To download this report, click ... next to the 'Performance Ratings+' section of the results summary tab and select 'View all answers' from the dropdown menu. Then, open the 'Compare groups' tab and click Download in the top, right-hand corner of the individuals table.

Columns included in this download: Participant, Reviewer, Rating, Rating description, Overall score, Review cycle

Performance ratings trends over time report

Allows you to see how performance rating distribution changed across selected cycles.

To download this report, click ... next to the 'Performance Ratings+' section of the results summary tab and select 'View all answers' from the dropdown menu. Then, open the 'Trends over time' tab and click Download in the top, right-hand corner of the Trends over time chart.

Columns included in this download: Review cycle, Review cycle ID, Review cycle start date, Review cycle end date, Ratings category (there's a column for each category)

Performance ratings trends over time/participant view report

Includes a full list of all participants that match selected filters and what performance rating category and score they received for all selected review cycles.

To download this report, click ... next to the 'Performance Ratings+' section of the results summary tab and select 'View all answers' from the dropdown menu. Then, open the 'Trends over time' tab and click Download in the top, right-hand corner of the individuals table.Columns included in this download: Participant, Reviewer, Rating, Rating description, Overall score, Review cycle


Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) ❓

How are performance ratings calculated?

Performance ratings incorporate weights and questions included in your custom PR+ formula. They're calculated using the formula below:
PerformanceRatingsFormula.png

When normalizing the opinion scales, we calculate them using the following formula:

Performance-Ratings-Formula.png

For example, let's say that you created a Performance Ratings formula in which manager reviews were weighted at 100%. The manager rated an employee all 3s, and questions were rated on a 4-point scale. The employee's performance rating would be 66%.

Performance-Ratings-Example.png

✏️

Note

We use "1" as the minimum value because, otherwise, all of the normalized scores would be skewed more positively. This means that if a person is rated 1 on all included questions, their performance rating would be 0%.

Can I change a performance rating manually?

No. Performance ratings are auto-calculated based on your weighted formula, and cannot be manually adjusted.

💡

Tip

If you want managers to have more influence over final performance outcomes, consider adding a Private Manager Assessment question about overall performance and including that question in your ratings formula.

When is Performance Ratings+ reporting available?

Performance ratings reporting becomes available as soon as reviews are submitted.

If questions used in your Performance Ratings+ formula are edited during calibration sessions, scores will automatically recalculate after changes are made.

Do edits made during calibration affect PR+ reports?

Yes, but only after calibration sessions are locked. Until then, PR+ data will not reflect in-progress changes.

How do performance ratings feed into the HR Outcomes Dashboard?

The HR Outcomes Dashboard uses your Performance Ratings+ rubric to categorize employees as high, mid, or low performers:

  • Top performers come from the top category of your PR+ rubric.
  • Bottom performers come from the bottom category.
  • Mid performers are calculated from all the categories in between.

For example, let’s say your performance ratings rubric includes the following five categories: Unsatisfactory, Needs Improvement, Meets Expectations, Exceeds Expectations, Exceptional.

In this case:

  • Top performers = Employees rated as Exceptional
  • Mid performers = Those rated Exceeds Expectations, Meets Expectations, or Needs Improvement
  • Bottom performers = Employees rated as Unsatisfactory

These classifications power the “% Top Performers,” “% Mid Performers,” and “% Bottom Performers” metrics in the HR Outcomes Dashboard.

Help Center article 💡: Measure Performance Using the HR Outcomes Dashboard


Was this article helpful?

We're sorry to hear that.

Please tell us why →