Best practices for Best-Self Review®

Are you new to the Best-Self Review®? Or are you looking to make more out of your upcoming review cycle? These best practices will help set you and your team up for success!

Best practices for review cycles

1.  Manage review admins: Who needs to be able to have access to see all reviews? And who will be the primary person in charge of setting up review cycles and questions?  For some teams this may be the CEO; for other teams, this may be the head of HR. Make sure you give the right people review admin permissions.

2. Add an additional manager for participants: Some participants might need more than one "manager" with the ability to view their review results. This is a common ask for people with a dotted line manager or for a participant who has recently had a manager change and that new manager needs insight into recent cycles. Review administrators can add an additional manager for viewing purposes via the 'Edit individual settings' page for any participant. This option is available for any current or past review cycle. 

3. Ask reflective and forward-thinking questions: Research shows that asking growth and development focused questions improves performance and aligns the team member with company objectives.

4. Company values assessment: If your company adheres to company values you will need to customize this setting when creating your Question template. Adding values to your review process allows your team members to focus in on the primary objectives of the company and the culture they wish to maintain.

5. Competency assessment: This assessment is a research-backed approach to gauge an individual’s skills and behaviors that drive performance. It gives employees and managers the ability to objectively and more holistically measure performance over time, identify skills and perception gaps, and enhances transparency in the review process.



The Private Manager Assessment section of the manager review works to reduce the idiosyncratic rater bias. Adam Grant recommends companies triangulate the Private Manager Assessment (the Deloitte questions in the default self+manager template) with as many objective measures of both results and behaviors as possible. Resources for Your Review (which includes past 15Fives, Objectives, etc...) helps to ensure the Private Manager Assessment is triangulated with as many Objective results as possible. The Competency Assessment helps to ensure the Private Manager Assessment is triangulated with as many behaviors as possible. This process (the private manager assessment triangulated with both results and behaviors) helps to ensure a more objective and fair review.

6. Setup your deadlines for review submissions: By default we suggest that the self-review be performed first, then the manager review. This allows the manager time to review the self-review submissions and focus in on their own responses before sharing the results with the team member.While the deadlines are soft and allow for submissions up until the cycle is locked by a review admin, the dates can also be edited after the cycle has already begun.

7. Share results: When a manager shares results with their direct reports it allows both parties to see each other's responses. Sharing is followed by a meeting to go over them and compare the responses. 15Five suggests meeting with your team before sharing the results of the review cycle. Managers should deliver feedback first in person, to avoid the text being misinterpreted before the final meeting is held. We do not suggest this be a time for a compensation review however this prepares you for a separate conversation for compensation advancement.

Check out these additional resources ⬇️:

Science 🔬: Best-Self Review

Video 🎥: Sleigh your next Best-Self Review™ Webinar

Video 🎥: Competency Assessment- Why and Best Practices

Was this article helpful?
2 out of 5 found this helpful